Atogatog is not a good card.
Though, to be fair, I honestly really like Atogatog. Flavor-wise, it’s amazing; seeing every Atog in the game on one card (at the time, at least; Megatog broke this by being printed later). As far as a 5-color commander goes, I would much rather play Child of Alara or Progenitus. Sadly, an Atog-themed Commander deck is unlikely, as there aren’t very many atogs, as you can see here.


